Barr, Efficient and Effective Central Banking: Beyond the Balance Sheet

FEDERAL RESERVE ·

An official website of the United States Government Official websites use .gov A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States. Secure .gov websites use HTTPS A lock ( ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. At the Money Marketeers of New York University, New York, New York Thank you for the opportunity to speak to you today. 1 There has been a lot of discussion of late about reducing the size of the balance sheet of the Federal Reserve to reduce our "footprint" in the financial system. I think it is important to frame the discussion, first by being clear about the nature of the problem to be solved and then weighing the tradeoffs of any remedies. I think shrinking the balance sheet is the wrong objective, and many of the proposals to meet this objective would undermine bank resilience, impede money market functioning, and, ultimately, threaten financial stability. Some would actually increase the Fed's footprint in financial markets. That's because the Fed's footprint in the financial system consists not only of the duration, composition, and size of our balance sheet (which are distinct issues), but also our roles in promoting the safety and soundness of banks, running the backbone of the payment system, and supporting financial stability. It doesn't make sense to talk about "the Fed's footprint" without taking into account these key functions and the way they interact. Some of the prominent proposals to reduce the Fed's balance sheet would have perverse effects that would actually increase the Fed's footprint in the financial system. For example, some proposals would increase the frequency of Fed lending and transactions in markets, both to implement monetary policy on an ongoing basis and, in extremis, to engage in interventions to preserve financial stability. Today I am going talk about what I see as efficient and effective central banking—central banking that holistically implements monetary policy, provides meaningful oversight of financial institutions, supports payment system functioning, and, in the Fed's case, also includes serving as the fiscal agent to the Treasury Department. We can't ignore any of these responsibilities, so when considering changes to our policies and practices, we need to consider the spillovers to our other duties and evaluate the tradeoffs. This integrated approach to central banking is essential to achieving the Fed's multiple objectives. I will make two broad points today. First, the size of the Fed's balance sheet is the wrong measure of the Fed's footprint in financial markets, and, second, many of the proposals being floated to address this purported problem would make our monetary policy operations less efficient and effective and raise financial stability risks. The Fed's Balance Sheet Let's start with an understanding of the Fed's balance sheet. The Fed's liabilities largely consist of reserve balances (the deposits that commercial banks hold with the Fed), currency in circulation, and the balance of the Treasury General Account (TGA), which is the Treasury's account with the Federal Reserve. 2 The Fed's assets are mostly Treasury securities, and we also have a sizable portfolio of agency mortgage-backed securities (MBS), most recently acquired in response to the COVID-19 crisis to address the extraordinary conditions at that time. 3 The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) conducts monetary policy with an ample-reserves regime. This means that control of our policy rate, the federal funds rate, is accomplished primarily by setting our administered rates, particularly the interest on reserve balances (IORB) rate. You can think of this regime graphically, as the Fed supplying reserves on the flat portion of the reserve demand curve, so that normal changes in the supply and demand for reserves lead to only limited variations in price. 4 In an ample-reserves regime, when we are getting it right, there should be limited money market volatility under normal conditions. The Role of Reserves in the Banking System Currently, reserves, which as I said are deposits of depository institutions at the Fed, represent $3 trillion of the Fed's $6.5 trillion in liabilities. Some recent proposals have focused on shrinking reserve demand as a means of facilitating a shrinking of our balance sheet. Let me take a step back and explain why supplying reserves is so important. As Chair Jerome Powell explained in a speech last year: "Reserves are the safest and most liquid asset in the financial system, and only the Fed can create them. The adequate provision of reserves is essential to the safety and soundness of our banking system, the resilience and efficiency of our payments system, and ultimately the stability of our economy." 5 Our provision of reserves has broader and important benefits beyond monetary policy implementation. If banks don't have enough reserves, the payment system suffers, because it gives them an incentive to economize on their liquidity by slowing down their outgoing payments, leading to bottlenecks and stresses in funding markets. And, as we know, during stress if banks do not have enough reserves when depositors ask for withdrawals, panic can ensue. These aren't theoretical problems, which is why we have regulations that support sound liquidity risk management, and reserves play an important role in banks' portfolios of high-quality liquid assets (HQLA). The indispensable benefits of the Fed's reserve provision need to be at the forefront of any discussion about our balance sheet. Furthermore, creating reserves is costless to the Fed. The Fed pays interest on reserves but also receives interest on the other side of the balance sheet, which is largely in the form of Treasury securities. 6 All the Fed's excess earnings go back to the taxpayer. 7 Implementing Monetary Policy Efficiently and Effectively Let me now turn to efficient and effective monetary policy implementation. In keeping with our commitment to effective implementation, after substantially shrinking the balance sheet for a couple of years, the Fed is now slowly growing our balance sheet to keep up with demand for our liabilities. Over the many decades since our creation, we typically have grown our balance sheet through gradual purchases of Treasury securities, to ensure we continue to meet demand for our liabilities as the economy grows, consistent with our monetary policy implementation regime. Currently, the additions to the Fed's balance sheet are incremental, and we are buying Treasury bills. Others have explained our reserve management purchases, so I will not repeat that here. 8 Instead, I will get straight to a discussion on how I see monetary policy implementation today as efficient and effective. Effective monetary policy implementation means that the federal funds rate, as well as other short-term interest rates such as repo rates, should trade near the rate the Fed pays on reserve balances. The current regime has achieved that for many years. Effective policy implementation also supports smooth market functioning.

AI 시장 분석

A Fed official said targeting balance-sheet reduction is the wrong approach and warned against judging the Fed's 'footprint' solely by the size of remaining assets. Beyond the balance sheet, the Fed's multiple roles — payments operations, bank supervision for soundness, and financial-stability support — should be considered, and some reduction plans could actually increase market intervention frequency and systemic risk. He argued that an ample-reserves framework and IORB-centered operations improve monetary-policy efficiency and support short-term market and bank liquidity. The remarks lower the likelihood of rapid balance-sheet shrinkage, which is likely to directly affect liquidity and the yield structure across US Treasuries, MBS, and short-term funding markets.

상승 영향

하락 영향

AI가 생성한 분석으로 투자 자문이 아닙니다.

DYAX Investor Sentiment

Bullish (Long) 63% · Bearish (Short) 37%

362 participants

Related News

원문 보기 — FEDERAL RESERVE